Separation
by nsoroma79

Comment:
One of the better egg shots this challenge. I think you chose well in your use of selective desatration. Great color, good separation, and crisp image. Well done

Orange chromatography
by nico_blue

Comment:
I can clearly see the separation. I fee that the liquids and glass were very well shot. My only complaint would be the bottle in back. It seems to serve no pupose and does not enhance the shot IMO. Dreat color and nice sharp focus. Great job.

Sorry
by daztaz

Comment:
Great Idea and very well shot. I realy enjoy the way you allow the veiwer to read a little peice of the letter. It leaves the veiwer wanting more. I also feel the the bright red envelope works well with the shot. Fits the challenge nicely, tells a stor, and is well exucuted. I feel however that a ring or somthing of the sort would have added a little more to the story. But was not necessry well done.

Separation Anxiety
by love

Comment:
fits the challenge and is an interesting shot, I feel howver that it is a little soft and that the R is a little too dark to read well. I as it stands I feel its a pretty average shot.

Separated liquids (Not Jello)
by indianzfan

Comment:
fits the challenge. I don't feel this is a very exciting shot however. The technicaly pretty good just not interesting. The only problems I can see in the shot is the bubbles in the top liquid It looks ackward only having bubbles in one of the layers, and the shodaw at the top of the photo dosn't work for me. Not a bad shot. Better than average actualy.. It just dosn't interest me enough to reach my top 10.

From behind the white gate
by jrtodd

Comment:
very interesting shot. This is definately a new and creative composition. Suprisingly it works well for me. i also fel that it fits the challeng very well. I think i would like too have seen a couple of small changes however. I'st I would like to have the fur around the dogs neck a little crisper. Second I think the spots and dirt on the left side are a bit distracting. Overall a prety good shot.

I love my M&M's Seperated
by hdogg4u

Comment:
I feel that this photo fits the challenge pretty well. I do feel however that your DOF was a bit too narrow. I would have liked this better if the M&Ms in the fore ground had been in focus as well. The lighting and colors are enjoyable however.

The Promise
by rblanton

Comment:
good idea but the photo is so dark it took me a while to figure out what you were trying to show us. I think that this was either to closely cropped or to dark. The veiwer has to spend too much time figuring out what this is a photo of to enjoy the photo itself.

hello toothferry
by middelbosch

Comment:
cute photo. I feel that this was very well shot. however.I don't find it to be particularly enjoyable. While I will admit however it meets the challenge and does not feel like just another family snap shot. Decent shot. Just no my cup of tea.

Letting go...
by Nitin

Comment:
nice shot just a little to dark for my taste. I also feel the ring should be further off the finger. It wouldgive me a stronger feel of it leaving.