Modeling Session
by basia03

Comment:
From Critique club.

I disagree about the slanted horizon - look at the photographer - he is trying to make best of the model and some _unexpected_background_behind_the_model_!!! He sacrifices the orthonormallity and even himself - falling out of the frame!
The naked legs would trash the intrigue: "What did he see behind her? Why is it so important that even the color is irrelevant?"

I like this one a lot.

Curious George
by amandamiller

Comment:
To my taste - not sharp enough and over-exposed.
Monkey standing on the toes and leaning forward makes it alive if not this annoying tag (a hate those tags on clothes and toys and my kid hates them too :-))))

Finally.
by movieman

Comment:
Nothing to add to previous comments.
The expression of the eyes and missing mouth makes one woder: is he smiling or pouting?
May be a little softer details...

Busy bee
by Andelain

Comment:
From critique club.

This shot is exhibiting superb technique and knowledge of composition. The title is intriguing and fits the challenge. The only thing that leaves me uncomfortable is colors. The flower does not look "yummy" - the green cast spoils it and for the eye of a bee... The bees have a completely different than human colorspace in their vision ;-) they see green as us - grey.

Whats inside this paper bag?
by Yugioh

Comment:
From Critique Club.

For the challenge the composition is kinda doubtful. I'd love to see the edge of the paper. Textures and colors are xcellent, lighting is OK. I guess the low final score is due to the high competition in this challenge ;-)

Sailing World
by HRoxas

Comment:
Colors are good but not sharp enough. Overprocessed?

Backpacker Magazine - Post Holing in Bandelier National Monument
by brett2004

Comment:
Where are the eyes??

Disc Dog Quarterly
by wetland

Comment:
:-)))))))

Travel and Leisure
by lizzyc3

Comment:
B-r-r-r-r-r-r.... Chilly!

sonny portrait
by jbruno1397

Comment:
Looks like hot fixage... The composition is great but this granularity adds nothing. Also the mid-tone range is lost somewhere.