Relaxation
by Kekiinani

Comment:
this image is perhaps a tad too light, or low contrast. It also seems that it was taken with a long delay, with a sligh breeze in the air, creating what seems to be camera shake... which i imageine is not. I think the biggest problem with this image is the range of shades of black to white.... it seems very middle grey.

Ghostly Delight
by eaponygyrl

Comment:
This image is very blurry which is one reason i gave it a low mark. Perhaps you were wanting to use that as part of the effect, but i don't feel it helps it at all. The subject is also placed DIRECTLY in the center of the image which makes for an 'uninteresting' composition... perhaps if it was moved to the left side more, that would help.

Autumn Night Colours
by SteveJ

Comment:
the direct lighting of the flash makes for a very cotrasty stagnant photo. The subject is nicely colored, but is the subject is not presented in a way that makes me think, or is anything other than what i would see if i looked at it for one second in real life. show me something i would miss if i wa walking by. The image also does not show any 'night' in it... it just happened to be dark when you shot the image.

Standing Tall - Against The "Flash"
by Drake

Comment:
An allright, image, with decent cropping, but it doens't have much appeal for me. It appears there is one direct light sourche which makes for a very contrasty uninteresting image.... i guess the subject doens't appeal to me that much.. it would take a creative viewpoint to creat interest for me. Perhaps next time, take an obscure vantage point, or one not normally seen.

Curl
by blemt

Comment:
nice detail and attention to parts. it is not quite as sharp as i would like it.. perhaps a square framing would work better for this, i am not sure what bothers me about it. Decent image.. good background color, perhaps a little boost of contrast would help this image a little.
-from the critique club.

The heart of Sampdoria Stadium
by maniman

Comment:
looks like a lot of action. All the people make an interesting composition. it is very busy, which can be ok and the people make a nice sort of 'blank' background, but the action in the image, which is perhaps the large flag, is very centered and in a 'boring' position in the photo. It is perhaps a little light, or too low contrast. I don't see any dark blacks... it is good to see the whole range of grey, from total white, to total black, with grey's in the middle.. even if it is a high key (very white) or dark image... there should be a good tonal range.

from the critique club.

A flower for you.
by slynneblarp

Comment:
good focus on the flower, and somewhat interesting photo. I am not sure the hand adds to the picture or not. It is blurry which brings out the flower, but it is still visible enough to know it is a hand.. and makes us think about it.. but not rellly intersting enough to keep our attention. Perhaps if a bit of the child was in the background, or no hand, or something. Good colors in the flower.
-from the critique club.

Part Tree Part Sky
by chaka

Comment:
Interesting image. it looks like you burned the sky or did something selectivly to the sky, or tree as there is a visible line on the left most branch. .. nice background and nice contrast between the branches and sky. The framing is a little stale perhaps.. it is rather locked and doesn't create tons of interest. Perhaps up the constrast a bit.. the image is pretty middle grey everywhere...
good start.
-from the critique club.

Nightfall on a Fall Night
by dphillips

Comment:
perhaps the tree's were moving.. perhaps you liked the sort of abstract look, .. it is a nice blend of color.. but it doesn't appeal to me very much.

Sleeping GIANT
by dacrazyrn

Comment:
i think this could have been really great, but it seems way too over saturated.