Father and Son
by basia03

Comment:
thanks a lot for all your helpful comments... by the way, i really liked the shine on their bald heads, too................

Chaplin: Undisputed Master of the Silent World
by redmoon

Comment:
oh, this is a great idea! i wanted to do something along the same lines, but couldn't really grasp the presentation... just thought i'd title it "before the talkies" - but back to your picture... focus is a little soft, isn't it? and one degree rotation to the left would've helped here... but, like i said, i just love the idea! 5.

You Can Silence the Noise...But Never the People
by mamonell

Comment:
your message escapes me, i'm sorry to say... technically, the picture suffers from a bad crop... the colors of the flag could've been more vivid, too... whether or not it conveys silence i can't tell and it doesn't really matter... 2.

Earplugs
by helgihelgi

Comment:
well, as earplugs go, it's a fine pair... that was the positive part of my comment... whether or not this picture conveys silence doesn't really matter... it has no appeal... there is nothing here to hold my interest... 2.

Pin Drop
by lizbeth010

Comment:
can't really tell if it's dropping, can you? whether or not it conveys silence doesn't really matter here... as entry into a photography contest it's weak... then again, it could be somebody's "honest" try for a brown ribbon, you just never know these days... whatever... 2.

"THE LIGHT AT THE END OF THE TUNNEL"
by mpradeep

Comment:
lighter parts of this picture are over blown... the round things behinds your model's head are distracting... all together it has no appeal... whether or not it conveys silence doesn't really matter here... as entry into a photography contest it's weak... 2.

I wish I could talk
by hallswel

Comment:
oh wow, the thumbnail looked cute, but the picture itself is much too small to be seriously considered... whether or not it conveys silence doesn't really make any difference here... 2.

Time Out
by elsapo

Comment:
much too small and not very interesting... it may or may not convey silence, but it doesn't really matter... 2.

Awaken
by Catnipp

Comment:
i rarely give ones, and unfortunately this is the case - as far as the composition, color, subject and technical presentation go separately or all together this amounts to one weak submission... it may or may not convey silence, but it doesn't make any difference...

silenced
by Whiskey

Comment:
i like the picture but not the idea of a cute little dawggy wearing a muzzle... i do hope you only use(d) it as a photographic prop... nice black and white, nice composition, conveys emotion well... 8.