at rest
by ursula

Comment:
I love the editing on this, great composition as well.

These hands are mine
by xXxscarletxXx

Comment:
Excellent, favorite of the challenge thus far. Great face, great expression, I like the framing with the hands, one minor critique, I'd like that whole pinky in the frame.

Daddy's Always There
by O'Holleran

Comment:
Very nice, maybe try it with a darker background?

el borracho
by arsenal

Comment:
Very well done. Has a Joey feel to it.

Working hands
by cimarron98

Comment:
Great subject and editing. I really like the overall effect but I'm not sure about the composition.

wrapped around your finger
by tate

Comment:
Excellent. Full of emotion, it tells a story.

I should bring money back home!
by kiumars_kashani

Comment:
Nice take on the challenge. Great portrait.

Let's play!
by AnnaP

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club Anna,

Cool Border collies! I have two myself.

You received some really good comments on this that I feel offer you a lot of insight. The brick wall and the framing alone would make for a really good shot alone, and the dogs playing in the snow would also make for a good shot. With both in the same shot they are competing for attention and overwhelm the viewer. When I look at the photo I see the brick wall, and then it�s like �hey there are two dogs down there too.� One or the other would be better for me.

Technical wise, the snow is very over exposed. Shooting a photo with part snow and part not snow is difficult. Also, the photo is not really sharp and could use a little tweeking of the colors.

Hope you find this helpful. Good luck on future challenges!

The Photographer
by LucidLotus

Comment:
I like the composition and over all I like the photo. Critique wise, I'd like to see more contrast in the plants. They all same to be pretty much the same shade and the guy is the same shade. Also, if I were not a photographer I might not know what the heck the guy is doing and why he has a steel pole coming out from between his legs.

Colour Me Greed
by IreneM

Comment:
kind of a stretch on the challenge, but simply an amazing photo.