Honey Aroma
by cosmofire

Comment:
Too central

Aromatic
by amsmyth

Comment:
Good detail. Perhaps slightly, ever so slightly over lit.

Smell-less
by kinks

Comment:
Doesn't fit in the topic for me. I'd further venture that saturation and focus have been compromised.

Dog and Foot
by SMW409

Comment:
Exposure and lack of punctum are problems. Dogs and feet smell so I don't know how this fits in with scent and aroma.

Hint of a Scent
by Neuferland

Comment:
Well handled, good exposure.

Lemon-fresh Scent
by HRoxas

Comment:
From the number of images that I have looked at for this challenge specifically I am coming to the conclusion that physical limitation of the equipment being used accounts for the DOF problems and this image is no exception. If there is a limit in the camera, surely the author ought to be aware and work to those limitations.

smells like winter
by ursula

Comment:
Pretty scene but strong line bisects in the middle. Not sure how you tie into the tpoic for the challenge but I don't make the connection.

Aromatic gravity
by frankh

Comment:
Good. Nice red saturation. Nice horizontal line on a third. Could be a fraction sharper.

Aroma stick
by Boyana

Comment:
Composition lets it down. Sometimes less is more and you seems to have tried more.

Achooooo!!!! ....bless you.
by Nukkta

Comment:
Not quite crisp enough. Could possibly do with some reflected light from the front.