Which one to choose?? hmmmm...
by andlb

Comment:
This is funny. But it cannot be to the Canon advantage as you compare the price of a camera with the price of the car. And if you mean to make advertise for a Mazda as beeing so cheap, why is not the Mazda in focus instead? Well, the idea is good anyway.

Cross into the blue
by Jason

Comment:
I love this picture very much. But I don't quite understand the idea. how does it meet the challenge. I am willing to change my vote if you will get back to me and explain. Because it might be a good propaganda idea that escapes my understanding. Right now I will rate it a 5. The photo, outside the challenge would be worthed a 10.

A rose is a rose is a rose...
by robert ellison

Comment:
Greetings from The Critique Club!

Nice picture to comment on. Pleasant subjects. Rose so frail, so ephemere and the stone, so hard, so eternal... I wish you used better that diagonal so it would direct my eyes up instead of down. A rotation of 90 degrees Left would have done miracles. I would be very happy if you will try it at least. You should pay more attention to the shadows. The refracted light by the bottle is distracting from the beauty of the whole. Harsh reflections or harsh shadows rarely add to a picture. You tried to enhance it in Photoshop I think but something happened there as the photo has so much noise. It is more visible on the rose and on the shadows of the stones. But, overall I think you did fine, it is only your third submission. You are getting better and better. Keep up the good work.
Best regards,
Elena

Where the Red Fern Grows
by Sheila_Lawson

Comment:
Another diagonal well used. Good DOF, nice contrasting colours, almost good lighting. The red leave or branch has a few hot spots. Still a very good photo. 9

Morning Mist
by van9338

Comment:
My god, where are you from to have such a beauty at this time of the year... Looks so fraile ... I like the use of the diagonal in the picture. 10

God in the Dock by C.S. Lewis
by dsidwell

Comment:
Wonderful picture. I just love the reflections. 10

Lonesome Dove
by scrum8

Comment:
Beautiful dove. I love the warm light you have captured. Is it a sunset? Good DOF. I wish you cropped it a bit from the left as for a better use of rule of thirds but is still a very nice picture. 9

The Mystery of the Old Castle by Marjorie Zimmerman
by agwright

Comment:
They should forbid people like you to take pictures. A few more like you out there and all the rest of the photographers will be useless. Dreamlike landscape. 10

Milk In My Coffee
by shutterfly

Comment:
The lighting is wonderful. I never get my lighting right. I keep looking and looking at this one but it has to end as I still have some pictures to rate. I know anyway that I'll be looking at it for the whole next week. I hope I will. 10

The Icky Sticky Frog
by Simplicity

Comment:
Nice photo, nice model. I wish I had such a model at home. My only complain: why did you chopped up the finger? I still like it so I will give it a 10.