Lower Scores
by jimmythefish

Comment:
I'm still new to photography... I don't 'get' this? :-/ I certainly won't take off for me not understanding. I really like this shot and the way it's cropped.

The Richest Country in the World...
by kosmikkreeper

Comment:
This could use some color enhancement. The colors aren't vibrant, they seem washed out. In fact, the leaves in the background almost look gray. Were you trying to desaturate the pic and leave only red and skin color? A bit of unsharp mask would've helped this too.

Nice shot, though.

Horsepower Vs. Cowpower
by Mona

Comment:
The cow doesn't seem to concerned...and I'm not sure I would've gotten out to move him, either!

Nice shot.

It would've been funny if you titled this "Moooove it". ;-)

Eternal Irony
by collinsjul

Comment:
Ware-Wulf...heh, funny!

As for critique, I'm wondering if you used curves (or similar) to adjust the colors of the image. The pine needles seem extremely orange and not real too me. They are colors that fall leaves would typically be; not pine. (not that I've seen anyway!)

Nice catch.

Drink Milk
by Dim7

Comment:
Unfortunately this doesn't look real enough for me. The water is very white while the milk has a yellowish tint to it. The glass of milk isn't blending in with the picture very well because of that color difference and because of the overall texture of the image - the photo isn't as clear as the glass of milk and the photo is grainy.

I think the idea is interesting and original, though. Nice try.

Diet Soda Fixes Everything
by LucidLotus

Comment:
Nice idea for a shot.

First, this is much too blurry. The red in the background is pixelated and at the base of it it appears to be glowing blue. (Caused by over-sharpening?) The line created where the red ends and the white begins 'cuts through' the picture - right through the Coke and the wine glass. I believe the crop could have been made better by including all of the spoon, the fork, and the wine glass.

Nice try, though.

ironless
by mackinla

Comment:
The background is too busy. Also, the iron idea seems to be a popular one this time.

Nice try, though.

Do As I Say, Not As I Do
by WildflowerJoy

Comment:
Great setup! Like the way you cropped this, too.

A good FLIGHT photo.........if I were a member
by scrum8

Comment:
Nice shot of the bird. However, it's seems like a stretch on the theme since there isn't really anything ironic about the picture itself.

If this were in the flight contest I probably would've given it a 4 or 5. The crop seems a big tight to me. Also the line in the background cuts right through the bird. Depending on what the original looks like, I wouldn't have cropped so tight, would've placed the bird in one of the right corners (to give it room to 'fly') to follow the Rule of Thirds a little better.

Overall, decent shot, though.

Ice on fire
by oskar

Comment:
Great shot, nice set up!

The only thing I noticed out of place are the dots (?) in the top left corner. Not sure what they are caused by.