Shrouded
by paynekj

Comment:
This looks red to me, and the tiny strings that go over the right eye kind of bug me.
However, I like that you can see the contours of the face through the fabric, and composition wise this image is interesting.
I am going to give this a 5 for now, but possibly re-calibrate my monitor in case it is off, and then come back and see if this looks any more orange to me.

The Ring!
by Judi

Comment:
Love this! Vibrant orange, and I love the symmetry in their legs.
I absolutely see why you chose to crop out their faces, and I think that was a good choice on your part. However, it is kind of odd that the viewing of the ring is so high up in the frame, it really makes my eyes want to look higher. Maybe you could have cropped at the shoulder instead, or changed the camera angle?
I don't know, its tough, I see why and I like the cropping you chose, but at the same time it bugs me.
Regardless, I still love the shot! 9

Love at first sight: Google Nexus One
by Nordlys

Comment:
I find this to be slightly boring with mediocre lighting
But....Can't......resist....Wall-e....
Must...score...more...highly...than previously intended.

Amber Blossom From The Spring Floral Collection
by J-Me

Comment:
Since this is a product shot, the whole thing should be in focus. However, the bottom quarter isn't, and that really detracts for me, especially as it is done with seemingly no purpose. 5

"Angel's Embrace" (CW)
by JokersSoul

Comment:
I own this! :-)
There is not much wrong with this image, however, it needs something to stand out from the crowd. The plain white background with mediocrely lit piece is kind of boring. It needs a "wow" factor that would compel voters to go for those 7s 8s 9s and 10s. A 5 from me.

The bitter jumpstart
by ahmadbaara

Comment:
A larger aperture that would result in the cup being more in focus would benefit this photo I think. However, I do like the overall image, the colors, and the mood.

Citizen DIve Watch
by bob_bobski

Comment:
There is a ton of dust/speckly stuff in here. I would have clones that out, it makes it seem less clean.

Tabasco- made with peppers
by kellmak10

Comment:
Brilliant! This goes to show that one must look at all images close up :-) This is not noticeable in thumb form. I am super impressed, and I hope it ribbons. 10

Electric Sunglasses
by dborto

Comment:
I think for this to really be a product shot, the whole image should have been in focus. 5

La Gazza Ladra (The Thieving Magpie)
by gyaban

Comment:
This is my favorite picture in this challenge. I hope it does really well.
The shadow and the feather make this "product" very interesting and set its apart from your competitors without turning it into a commercial like some of the images in this challenge