Here's Looking at You
by imagehounds

Comment:
I really love how the mannequin really does appear to be connecting with the camera, and therefore with the viewer. Who knew that an inanimate object could could connect like that. The yellow color cast is fairly glaring for me though, I would have tried to do some correcting with curves. 7

She's all done shopping.
by sjhuls

Comment:
What an adorable pouting expression she has. And for once I think the border adds a nice touch.
The portrait comes off a bit too soft for me though, I think it needs just a bit more focus .6

Abu Omar Flaifil exhaust welding 079/6386589
by HighNooner

Comment:
I really like the editing and it is a very interesting photo with a lot to look at. But I am missing the "window shopping" aspect. Would have scored this one higher in a free study, it is very interesting. Just not right for this challenge in my opinionn 5

Just what I want for Christmas!!!
by LonnieD

Comment:
Awesome humor in this photograph, and meets the challenge very well. I do think the focus is a little soft. Some topaz or something like that would have been great for this photo. I also would have tried to get rid of some of that yellow color cast.
This picture made me smile :-) 6

Stars
by kannewurf

Comment:
Great framing and overall composition. I am loving the lighting shadows on those mannequins. 7

Sacred Feather Hats
by giantmike

Comment:
There are many reflection shots in this challenge. But THIS is masterful. By far outperforms the others. I also love the editing you have chosen here. Topaz?
Really great shot, so very much to look at and to like. 9

peace of ceiling
by Donald

Comment:
This one is hard for me to decide on. Everything in this photo screams awkward to me, the angle, the window reflections, the fact the text is cut off etc. On the one hand I don't like the awkwardness, on the other hand, if that was your intention you succeeded masterfully, which should be rewarded. Anyways, it does meet the challenge well.

All I want for Cristmas
by beekeeper

Comment:
Lol, that glaring obnoxious open sign directly clashes will everything else in this photo that is so completely classy. I wonder what the store people were thinking! i am really loving that clash. Also loving the composition and that awesome stone wall. 7

The Ghost of Christmas Presents
by littlemav

Comment:
I love looking at this photo and trying to decide the story behind it. Very interesting to look at.
I understand that in editing you probably emphasized the yellow tinge on purpose, but it does come off a bit strong to me. 6

bear on a chair
by sandpitdiaries

Comment:
I am loving the editing done on this. The muted color tones are very nice.
I think a lower angle would have been even more effecting by adding more impact.
Eye level is always the best, and that bear does have eyes :-) 6