Black is Black I want My Baby Back
by Mona

Comment:
seems a bit soft or out of focus
did meet the challenge

Black Tie Affair
by fisheye

Comment:
didn't meet the challenge ...shouldn't be anything but shades of black and white
nice clarity and reflection though

Apple
by pitsaman

Comment:
met the challenge ...subjectively, the apple doesn't do much for me

Reaching For My Heritage
by carlacryptic

Comment:
I looked up the word achromatic....just black and white...
nonetheless, nic dof

Ingredients for Romance
by Shelley

Comment:
Its difficult to critique this shot. Clarity and color are wonderful...so is the composition and lighting. Great shot. I love the uncovered peice of chocolate. Great shot. I also love the lighting off of the wine glasses. I just happened to scroll down and noticed a comment that someone made about getting rid of yourself in the picture....I did not see that.

OREO 'n' MILK
by theodor38

Comment:
I think your idea is excellent; however I think it would have been more profound if you could of taken it while dunking a cookie and seeing the milk droplets falling into the glass. Secondly the focus looks a bit soft...but then I am doing this first thing in the morning and maybe I am not quite focused. I love the overall composition and especially the black background

Ice Storm
by GolferDDS

Comment:
love the ice crystals

Shallow Glass
by A Weaver

Comment:
very creative

chilly dog
by Seanachai

Comment:
nice dof...cute dog

Pink Geranium
by qnjt

Comment:
beautiful flowers and dof