Not a drop
by Dez

Comment:
Nice glass. I really enjoy the textures I can see here, and the camera angle is cool. The black background is nice too. The DOF you used is interesting... not sure if it works or not. Actually, I think it does, because it pulls the eyes down to that cow print image on the glass. I have a feeling that I'd have liked some more negative space around the image... maybe above the glass? The tight frame just makes it a bit bland to me.

Got Milk?
by arnit

Comment:
Arnit... I was at first kind of annoyed at the idea of such a famous photo being retaken for another challenge. But, I just looked back at "Got Toast", and read all those comments (I wasn't here for that challenge), and I realised that having another chance to do this photo and have it taken for what it is, a great idea, without all the doubt about it being faked in photoshop, must be really satisfying for you! And this time, it shows even more flair. All that milk hanging in the air, with the snow on the ground and the beautiful clouds, makes this an amazing photo. So, I'm keeping an open mind and giving it 10 :).

Refreshing
by spiderman

Comment:
Strange and a bit grotesque! Is this the same bearded man who was in that tongue shot in the "Body Parts" challenge? If so, he's a great subject for your photos... willing to do all kinds of things :). I like photos of people who look "real", and not classically photogenic.

The milk splash effect is very well captured, but I think the lighting is too strong, making UFO shaped shadows on your background.

Got Cookies
by daysez

Comment:
A plain but well shot setup photo. Interesting that there seem to be about 5 shadows behind that milk glass! The lighting could do with a bit more work, I think... more diffusion to make the shadows softer. I'm not a fan of a big, square crop either... it makes a photo difficult to read, in my opinion.

Where Frozen Milk Comes From
by alanfreed

Comment:
Pleasant landscape shot, but not much to tie it to the challenge. I like the soft light and undulating hills, so it gets a decent score from me anyway :).

Tranqulity on Heirisson Island
by lisae

Comment:
I missed an "i" out of "tranquility"!

Evening Tide
by a1leyez0nm3

Comment:
Amazing colours. A little bit lacking in subject matter. There isn't much to draw your eye.

SNOWFIELD
by howza

Comment:
Very interesting and differeint. I love the lumpy look to the snow, and the fence breaks it up, adding perfect focus and scale to pull the photo together. I'm giving this 10.

Beach Landscape. A closeup
by cbonsall

Comment:
Interesting approach to "landscape". I like it.

Southeast of Nye
by BadPigg

Comment:
Gorgeous. Great sense of space and scale. The composition is tight, the colours are glorious, and there are some very tactile textures in the rocks and grass. 10 from me.