Abandoned Silo
by LindaLee

Comment:
Very effective composition and great textures. Feels a little overexposed though. I don't feel as though I'm seeing all the texture here as well as I could.

Elephant Feet
by fsieradzki

Comment:
Interesting shot, but I'm not sure about the sense of perspective here. The shapes of the icicles are really weird and cool. The image seems tilted though.

Sleeping Puppy
by jnevitt

Comment:
There's another dog photo in this challenge that shows how far you can go with perspective in a dog portrait. This one has its charm, but the front lighting flattens it and there isn't quite enough nose to create a strong sense of perpective by itself!

A Bugs Life
by Fibre Optix

Comment:
This composition is highly centred. In this case it kind of works. I like central composition when it has a purpose. However, I find this photo a little uniniteresting this way. All the negative space around the man is kind of purposeless. A closer crop would be more effective I think.

I like the lens flare though, it really adds to the image :).

WWII-B36
by autool

Comment:
Seems like a very technically good image, but the subject isn't interesting to me. It's like something from a museum brochure, maybe. Dry and technical, but well done.

Different perspectives
by Gordon

Comment:
This is cool. It's fun to compare the different groups of people. Unfortunately, they're all so small, I can't really see their body languages as much as I'd like. A tighter crop maybe with just the top 2 levels might have been more effective (if it was possible, and the camera wasn't low end).

THE WALL
by Antithesis

Comment:
I think that the wall is a little too marginalised in this photo. It doesn't feel like it's the subject, more an element that distracts a bit from the breathtaking landscape.

A Window-cleaner's Nightmare
by FranziskaLang

Comment:
Wow, very nice mix of colour with black and white. The composition is very strong. It's pretty much technically perfect, but it's one of those photos where I feel the technique is stronger than the subject choice. On an emotional level it leaves me a bit cold.

tumbling dominoes
by MajorChaos

Comment:
I think this is a great idea, but the composition is very loose and scattered. A tighter shot, or shallow DOF that brings strong focus to some area of the photo would strengthen it.

Liberty and Justice for All - 2
by kevinswope

Comment:
Oops, earlier I thought there were only 2 American-flag-up-a-pole photos, but there are 4!! As I've said on the other two I've rated, it's hard for me to get over this symbolism, since I'm not American and I'm angry about the looming war. But this is a very strong photo. Of the 4, it's in the top 2 :).