Tack-y-cardia
by dbeau

Comment:
First impression missed the humor entirely. The whimsey and humor are clear and very well executed. This reviewer is totally embarrased by missing this the first run through for rating and has bumped it from a seven to a 10. Well done. A ribbon winner for sure.

Tack & Droplet
by dswann

Comment:
A clever idea and a technical success, it's less than successful in an artistic sense. DOF control is excellant and the lighting isn't over done creating blooms. The subject is less than interesting. Perhaps a different background with a slightly different angle would have helped. A little more thought and better framing would have brought the rating higher.

Class Reunion
by JuliBoc

Comment:
A clever idea and a technical success, it's less than successful in an artistic sense. DOF control is excellant and the lighting isn't over done creating blooms. The subject is less than interesting. A little more thought and better framing would have brought the rating higher.

Heads Up!
by MisterMarcus

Comment:
A clever idea and a technical success, it's less than successful in an artistic sense. DOF control is excellant and the lighting isn't over done creating blooms. The subject is less than interesting. Perhaps a different background with a slightly different angle would have helped. A little more thought and better framing would have brought the rating higher.

Sharp as a Tack!
by PennyStreet

Comment:
This image is a less than successful in an artistic sense. DOF control is excellant and the lighting isn't over done creating blooms. The subject is less than interesting. Perhaps a different background with a slightly different angle would have helped. A little more thought and better framing would have brought the rating higher.

• Underwater Attack •
by Bear_Music

Comment:
A clever idea and a technical success, it's less than successful in an artistic sense. DOF control is excellant and the lighting isn't over done creating blooms. The subject is less than interesting. Perhaps a different background with a slightly different angle would have helped. A little more thought and better framing would have brought the rating higher.

The Last One Standing
by nozl

Comment:
A clever idea and a artistic success, it's less than successful in a technnical sense. DOF control is excellant and the lighting isn't over done creating blooms. The subject is less than totally absorbing. Perhaps a different background with a slightly different angle would have helped, but the author's intent is clear. Originally rated a 7, it has been upped to an 8 and well deserved. A little more thought would have brought the rating even higher.

At-Tacked Gladiator
by brumer0

Comment:
Upon the initial rating pass, this reviewer lost sight of the humor behind this image and was distracted by the light on the helmet. While making the comment phase of rating the image, this reviewer recaptured his sense of humor and took a second look. This image is both an artistic and technical success and is laugh-out-loud funny. Originally rated a 7, this has been rerated a 10 and it's well worth that upgrade. If the there is any justice in the world, this image should be a ribbon winner. Well done - seriously, well done.

A Tack at Dawn
by sfalice

Comment:
A clever idea and a technical success, it's less than successful in an artistic sense. DOF control is good and the lighting isn't over done creating blooms. The subject is less than interesting and appears to be over sharpened. Perhaps a different background would have helped. A little more thought and better framing would have brought the rating higher.

Tacks Relief
by tfarrell23

Comment:
A clever idea and a technical success, it's less than successful in an artistic sense. DOF control is excellant and the lighting isn't over done creating blooms. The subject is less than interesting. Perhaps a different background with a slightly different angle would have helped. A little more thought and better framing would have brought the rating higher.