the only note she left
by hopper

Comment by merstone20:
this is really awesome. Love it. so creative.

the only note she left
by hopper

Comment by edwalk74:
Nice idea, I like how you don't need any explanation whatsoever.
She hates him, she left her ring he gave her, and the key to their place. Nice idea and way to execute. Nice Work.

the only note she left
by hopper

Comment by hopper:
The WPL has nothing to do with the way people vote on images

Originally posted by agenkin: One more argument why WPL is a bad thing for this site.

the only note she left
by hopper

Comment by agenkin:

Originally posted by hopper: I don't think it's very good and I dislike images like this ... but I also thought it could pull an average score which would help my team.

One more argument why WPL is a bad thing for this site.

Originally posted by hopper: no offense taken ... this image should not have won a ribbon

Good to hear the author say this, seriously.

the only note she left
by hopper

Comment by hopper:
no, you aren't the only one ... I agree with you 100% and I'm shocked that this could win. I'm in the WPL, that's the only reason I entered this photo. I don't think it's very good and I dislike images like this ... but I also thought it could pull an average score which would help my team.

no offense taken ... this image should not have won a ribbon

(edit to add) - I feel this way about a lot of images that win here, so I don't feel guilty at all about submitting an image I dislike in an attempt to win. It's just a game we're playing :)

Originally posted by rswank: Congratulations on the ribbon and seriously please do not take this personally, I mean no offense. Am I the only one who thinks this is rather chessy? Maybe it's b/c I have an inherent distaste for such obvious setups aimed squarely at attaining the inverse of a DNMC.

Message edited by author 2007-02-28 10:21:26.

the only note she left
by hopper

Comment by swankFoto:
Congratulations on the ribbon and seriously please do not take this personally, I mean no offense.
Am I the only one who thinks this is rather chessy?
Maybe it's b/c I have an inherent distaste for such obvious setups aimed squarely at attaining the inverse of a DNMC.

the only note she left
by hopper

Comment by GoldBerry:
Very cool idea! Great lighting too :-)

the only note she left
by hopper

Comment by SandyP:
Eeeee. . .that is very sad! But very creative and well done. "It's only a picture. It's only a picture. It's only a picture :)

Congratulations on a most effective illustration of the subject, and top honors to reward you for your creative skill!

the only note she left
by hopper

Comment by BethieB:
Congrats!!! Fabulous idea. Hope it never really happens!

the only note she left
by hopper

Comment by eqsite:
Maybe a few more of these will bring her back:


Nice job -- congrats on the ribbon!