November
by JohannesFrank

Comment by doctornick:
Way to much of a border. The actual picture gets too small and loses impact. That was potentially an 8 without that overwhelming border. A split neutral density filter could have helped increase the saturation in the sky while exposing the tress and house properly.

November
by JohannesFrank

Comment by colda:
whoa! easy on the border!
nice image, can clearly see it as a calendar, wish that I could look at the image without the border getting distracting so much though

November
by JohannesFrank

Comment by gruvin:
I like the way the negative space in the over-exposed sky anchors the earth to the water here.

November
by JohannesFrank

Comment by dipaulk:
I rarely comment on a person's borders, but this one just overwhelms what could have been a beautiful photo. I would have rated it higher without the frame/border.

November
by JohannesFrank

Comment by coolhar:
too much frame, not enough pic, I think I would have liked the photo but can't see much of it

November
by JohannesFrank

Comment by charmayne:
great scene...the framing is a little distracting on a calender shot for me, but would look great on the wall.

November
by JohannesFrank

Comment by siggi:
the frame is too heavy. realy distracts you from the image.
Usually I do -1 for a bad frame but you get -2 for the frame.
With there where some detail left in the sky but its all just washed out.

November
by JohannesFrank

Comment by Bud:
Great photo, I would rate this higher if it was better focused.

November
by JohannesFrank

Comment by RedOak:
This picture seems very interesting and nice. Unfortunatly, because of the "very big" frame, we do not see much of it. The colours look really rich, while the sky could've used some work.

As a recommendation, i would propose to remove the frame completly, and just add a little framing line, a few pixel-distance from the actual picture (black background) with a nice golden colour. This would bring out a lot more of the image.

An unwriten rule of framing: Never use the dominant or most 'foreground' colour as a frame display. Go with the soft and unique colours. (in your case, yellow, green or Red would've probably given more punch).

November
by JohannesFrank

Comment by smokeditor:
nice shot, border is a bit excessive and distracting