Peppar Popper
by tvsometime

Comment by avalanche1030:
Great shot - easily could see in a magazine

Cartier-Bresson Retake
by tvsometime

Comment by jotaga:
Very well done! You found a good location and a model with clothes that resemble HCB years. I also like the motion blur on her (beautiful) legs. Gave you an 8 but will bump you up. Hope that this was not staged.

Cartier-Bresson Retake
by tvsometime

Comment by giantmike:
In Cartier-Bresson style, I think the blur of movement is spot on. But I wonder if that will end up hurting your overall score (I would have likely take a point off for it without the title).

Cartier-Bresson Retake
by tvsometime

Comment by Tiny:
Like the movement and angle.

Carousel
by tvsometime

Comment by PenelopeK:
Back to comment. Lots to like here, great idea, great spinning top and circles of light. It meets the challenge. On the other hand, I find it rather busy with the fence and tree cutting me off from what is most interesting rather than adding to the image. Also, a small but "nagging" issue for me, I find the girl's white sandals distracting because my eye keeps getting drawn back there. On further reflection.. this nicely captures a child's wonder with the spinning carousel, and the fence acts to provide the feeling of a child being on "the outside" looking "in" at where all the fun is going on. Perhaps a title to reflect that would have helped me appreciate the photo more immediately but I don't know, it's just a thought. I'm glad I took to time to explore it further.

Carousel
by tvsometime

Comment by galatia_n:
It's nice...imho it's better if cropped focusing more to the little girl and the carousel.

Peppar Popper
by tvsometime

Comment by Revecca:
I like the reflection and the misty looking white around the bottle and the peppers.

Cartier-Bresson Retake
by tvsometime

Comment by Yo_Spiff:
Nice, um, er... shoes.

Carousel
by tvsometime

Comment by kellyo:
If only you'd come in closer to the carousel it would have been a cooler effect. The foreground fence, tree, & sidewalk take away a lot from the photo. Clearly meets the challenge.

Peppar Popper
by tvsometime

Comment by hesitant:
sharp and clear. a simpler, plainer background could add to this