Adobe
by DPC-System

Comment by orussell:
I love the image. Too bad that there's lots of artifacts and vertical banding in you sky (very strange effect from a camera - I've seen scanners do this - please don't take this as an accusation, it's not). Again very lovely image.

Adobe
by DPC-System

Comment by alien2thisworld:
Composition: 9, Love the framing of the first door
Technical: 8, Great tone range. Only thing I can suggest is to decrease the jpeg compression slightly so the shades in the sky are a little smoother
Appeal: 9
Challenge: 10, Shot could be directly out of Ansel's camera if I didn't know better
Overall Calculated Average Score: 9

Adobe
by DPC-System

Comment by rhipster:
Great Adams style work. Strange effect to see the top part of the church dark and the lower part well lit. Is this natural?. I love the texture of the materials.

Adobe
by DPC-System

Comment by jrtodd:
Very nice, very AA. A little more to the left and it is. This is my highest scoring photo.

Adobe
by DPC-System

Comment by hyperfocal:
My pick for the best of the challenge. Great Work.

Adobe
by DPC-System

Comment by Telehubbie:
I loved Ansels photo of this same spot. I can't find it anywhere online to compare, but very nicely done and true to the original from what I remember.

Adobe
by DPC-System

Comment by MWitt:
Excellent! Did you take measurements or what? (: I have this photo and it looks like you took it at the exact same spot and time as Ansel did. 10

Adobe
by DPC-System

Comment by vtruan:
Quite nice, fite the challenge well.

Adobe
by DPC-System

Comment by SnapperL:
i like the view "through a window" in this shot. It works. I also like the tops that compliment each other in there likeness of each other. it is interesting how in the window on the barn is much lighter then outside of the window. Is this how the photo took or was this a play with PS? - 7

Adobe
by DPC-System

Comment by Bud:
Great shot.