Autumn Leaves Quietly
by Imagineer

Comment by ProfT:
7 - like the composition - would score higher but the extreme foregournd bokeh is too intrusive for me

Autumn Leaves Quietly
by Imagineer

Comment by h2:
Technicals: 2/2 - good use of DOF, good exposure
Composition: 1.5/2 - diagonal combined with rule of thirds (almost); border is too bold
Challenge Relation: 1/2 - the book is there...
Originality/Creativity: 1/2
Overall Impact: 1.5/2
7 - among my top picks in this challenge

Autumn Leaves Quietly
by Imagineer

Comment by IreneM:
Great shot, b/w is just perfect for it.

Autumn Leaves Quietly
by Imagineer

Comment by idp:
Excellent

Autumn Leaves Quietly
by Imagineer

Comment by SoulMan1978:
nice DOF

Autumn Leaves Quietly
by Imagineer

Comment by rob_smith:
Nice photo

Autumn Leaves Quietly
by Imagineer

Comment by karmat:
i really like this as bw and i like how the row of chairs leads to the subject. nice take on the challenge

Autumn Leaves Quietly
by Imagineer

Comment by MistyMucky:
This is great. My favourite.

Autumn Leaves Quietly
by Imagineer

Comment by jonfrommk:
Without a shadow of doubt my favourite picture in the entire challenge

Love the POV and a fantastic dof which means although the viewer is some distance from the subject that they can see exactly what she is doing in great sharpness.

The pose looks very natural (if this is a genuine candid then I salute you for having been able to pull this off so well...If it isnt, well it looks like it is and is all the better for that)

Lovely black and white conversion and the border works exceptionally well

Its a big 9 from me

Autumn Leaves Quietly
by Imagineer

Comment by jschro:
Great foreground bokeh...were you a week late? Fits great into this challenge as well.