Wanna Cookie?
by karmat

Comment by carsten:
Good composition and the lighting is OK. Perfect focus and colours. Overall a great job.

At the Corner of Charles and Maple
by karmat

Comment by mjcecil:
Way to get aggressive with the viewpoint! This would have been a good time for fill-flash. The one stripe across Charles is OK, but the total shadow on Maple is tough to overcome.

Wanna Cookie?
by karmat

Comment by Anachronite:
maybe just a little too close of a shit... backing up a bit would really help out

At the Corner of Charles and Maple
by karmat

Comment by Bullwinkle:
Top marks for DOF in this image. The toppled sign and weathered tree trunk compliment each other well. The hint of bush on the right is a nice touch to soften the harsh sign edges. What does this image look like in B&W? I find the Maple St. sign a tad dark but that is probably the best you could do considering the shadow-highlight extremes under those conditions. Your vantage point is also well chosen. I would like to see the right corner of the Maple St. sign. Otherwise a very good effort.

At the Corner of Charles and Maple
by karmat

Comment by scroosloose:
Well done, nice perspective.

Wanna Cookie?
by karmat

Comment by lisae:
Good composition. There are a lot of milk and cookie photos in this challenge, but yours is more on the level of art than many of them.

At the Corner of Charles and Maple
by karmat

Comment by kiwiness:
The idea is good. Pity the Maple Street sign is a little to dark and the shadow falling across the Charles Street sign also distracts. But other than that I like the photo, especially against that crisp blue sky. Cool angles and good use of thirds!

Wanna Cookie?
by karmat

Comment by DougPaz:
Great focus and and I really like the angle although it looks unatural because of the lack of tilt of the milk. The only real nit is the number of glares in the glass. It appears that you needed something to soften the lights i.e. a sheet or reflector. Good shot.

Wanna Cookie?
by karmat

Comment by aussie:
Oh I love this macro shot. I really like how the milk hasn't been spilled and left a white mark on the glass, it is perfectly rounded in the glass. Excellent job there. Also, it makes me HUNGRY - LOL. Great work and GL.

Wanna Cookie?
by karmat

Comment by kandyj:
Very nice use of cropping and contrast, as well as claity. ONly thing I could think of changing was the blue spot on the glass and a little softer lighting to keep the harsh reflections of the glass less strong. Wonderful clarity of texture on the cookie, looks like I could reach up, grab it and swallow it whole!!