Mountain Bike Mud Pi
by karmat

Comment by SteveS:
Imaginative but a little obscure without the title.

Mountain Bike Mud Pi
by karmat

Comment by kiwiness:
Original! I prefer the pics of a natural pi sign like this one. Good job!

Sisters
by karmat

Comment by Fiver:
I like the over saturated look of the colors. Nice lines.

Sisters
by karmat

Comment by f-32:
Symmetry AND color! (Two HOT babes, too, these sisters!)

Sisters
by karmat

Comment by pncowley:
Nice approach to the challenge... could benefit, in my opinion, from a sharper focus. Also seems to be some chromatic abberation throughout the shot, particularly visible on the strings and the sharper edges in the shot.

Baby Steps
by karmat

Comment by Lustre:
Critique Club

Composition: The composition of this image is very good. The spacing around the shoes works well. I really like the mirror style effect you created.

Technical Quality: Technically the shot is ok, but could probably be improved slightly. The lighting is a little harsh, but nothing too serious. The focus looks a bit blurry - did you try sharpening the image to define some of the edges.

Meeting the Challenge: I really like your approach to the challenge. Your decision to make the shoes different was very wise - otherwise it would look like a shoe on a mirror (making for a rather boring photo). The shoelace was a good decision, the tab at the back probably wasn't necessary, but certainly isn't a problem.

Creativity: Again, a reflected shoe is a pretty boring subject. But a pretend reflection with an obvious difference was very smart. It's the kind of photo that if hung on a wall would have people look at it thinking "why photo that" until they realised the humour in it.

Border: The border is nice and subtle. Good job.

Overall: I really like the concept in this photo. It isn't technically perfect, with the focus being my main distraction. Good work on a very amusing photo.

When Life Gets You Down, Think BUBBLES!!
by karmat

Comment by justine:
CC Greetings karmat

Fits The Challenge-Yes
Composition- Good
Background- Good
My Opinion- I think the idea and background are the winners in this shot. If: the bubble was in focus and not yellow ring-and the colors brighter this would of pulled it all together. Like you said such is life! Over all it's a likable shot.

Sisters
by karmat

Comment by pinback:
Cool

Baby Steps
by karmat

Comment by Artifacts:
This was one of my top three choices for this challenge.

The quality of this image plus the deliberate joke poking fun at the "symmetry" theme was hilarious and incredibly well done. It has just the right amount of a warped sense of humor.

Sisters
by karmat

Comment by the sycamore samurai:
Gotta love a p-bass