- A Developing Skyline -
by andrewt

Comment by tpbremer:
I think your inclusion of the black border really shows that you don't have that much black in the actual image.

Also, its impressive that you still have a image with contrast despite the lack of extremes.

- A Developing Skyline -
by andrewt

Comment by Melethia:
It's hard to get a really good skyline/landscape in tones of gray and you did an EXCELLENT job with this - your work with it paid off nicely, I think. Suits this challenge very well. Congrats on the 5th place star thingie!

- A Developing Skyline -
by andrewt

Comment by ErikV:
Congrats on the HM! Nicely done.

Water Fun by Ashezz (IMAGE_ID=49999) : Dec2003 Water Challenge
by andrewt

Comment by tanguera:
A definite improvement. Nice contrast of tones and textures between the splash and the background.

Water Fun by Ashezz (IMAGE_ID=49999) : Dec2003 Water Challenge
by andrewt

Comment by zackdezon:
A very faithful and attractive reproduction!

- A Developing Skyline -
by andrewt

Comment by shutterbug8:
CONGRATS ON 5TH.Great image, I love it and choose it as a fav. Although I did not vote in this challenge...as I glanced over the entries, this one stood out. Now that it is over, I was very disappointed to see how many are giving out 1s 2s and 3s to "what IMO look like winners" This could have pulled in a ribbon had the low scorers surpressed their jealousy or whatever was going on with them. I repeat the comment of hahn23. This stood out as one to meet the challenge exactly. Great control (avoidance)of whites and blacks. Had I voted, this would have received a 9 or even 10 from me, and I give out only a few of these per challenge if any sometimes. But I will not give out a 1-2 and rarely a 3. If a photo is an apparent smack in the face to the challenge or voting community, I do not give it a low score, I just don't vote on it. But again that is an entrant that seems to be going out of their way be to go against the grain or rules etc.etc. I see too many great or good shots ending up with these 1s AND 2s. Yours did not deserve this.

- A Developing Skyline -
by andrewt

Comment by dougi555:
I shoudl have recoginsed Singapore, that's teh Fullerton on teh right isn't it? That shot can't be far from the F1 track is it? I love this, my highest scoring shot. Nice work.

- A Developing Skyline -
by andrewt

Comment by hahn23:
This really says gray to me. Great job on control (avoidance) of the whites and blacks. Fits the challenge very well. 9

- A Developing Skyline -
by andrewt

Comment by newmexicomtngirl:
this looks sooo futuristic

- A Developing Skyline -
by andrewt

Comment by PennyStreet:
The desat works for me in this as a grey image. Very nice perspective - love the shot!