x marks the spot ..of a lost button
by Atsugi

Comment by Blackbox:
This seems very simple but I like it a lot. The title makes it very emotive and sad. To me, the cloth background gives it some graininess but nothing more then to be expected. I hope this does well: 10

x marks the spot ..of a lost button
by Atsugi

Comment by rkligman:
Seems like the focus is just off

x marks the spot ..of a lost button
by Atsugi

Comment by AJSullivan:
I don't really get what the focus is on here. It seems the only thing that is clearly in focus is a small section of the tooth pick.

little brother biding his time
by Atsugi

Comment by oscarthepig:
Good idea, but the foreground rock does not stand out all that well. I think it could use a bit more contrast and maybe a little bump in the saturation. I really like how the trees to the left are framed. Overall, a very nice effort, though.

little brother biding his time
by Atsugi

Comment by FrankRobinson:
Technically DMC, well done there! Mystified by the title though.

little brother biding his time
by Atsugi

Comment by EL-ROI:
Great depth of field and exposure for all the available light. The image is kind of flat though.

don't fence me in
by Atsugi

Comment by ahjenny:
Interesting picture. I like that the fence is also not in focus.

don't fence me in
by Atsugi

Comment by Judi:
Darn fences...can't they make them invisible!

entertainment old to new (Circles)
by Atsugi

Comment by Ecce_Signum:
Greetings from Andi via the Critique Club

First Impression: This seems to be a very busy image and I find my eyes flitting from place to place never really settling on anything in particular apart from the bird droppings.

Composition: Well, you were in a moving tram so you were really stuck for moving around to get a better angle. The main focus is on the front dome but its a little central for my liking and think if you managed to capture the big wheel between the domes things would look a lot better. You could also have cropped out the foreground to where the main dome starts,

Subject: Yes, I can see cirlces (or parts of them) so this meets the challenge but doesn't go further than that for me sorry

Technical: A decent sky and the exposure doesn't have any major issues though the overall image is a little flat, lacking contrast and doesn't 'pop'. I don't think you needed F/22 here nomatter what end of the zoom you were on.

Final thoughts: As a reminder of your day out this is a keeper so if thats what you were aiming to achieve then your work is done :)

entertainment old to new (Circles)
by Atsugi

Comment by liberty:
Nice lighting and colors, but the circle isn't prominent enough, 5.