Pater Noster
by jmsetzler

Comment by GBrummett:
I like this shot.. nice grain!

Pater Noster
by jmsetzler

Comment by rex:
I am making two passes on this Challenge. I will vote on your photo then return later(before voting is over) to comment on what I like and dislike about your shot. You can take the comments however you wish and I will try not to be mean. Just don't take it the wrong way.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Real noisy but maybe that is what you were going for.

Pater Noster
by jmsetzler

Comment by reevey:
A bit too grainy, but I like the composition.

Liberty And Justice
by jmsetzler

Comment by yadin klein:
this is a great shot and a keep trying to do this on my own but the water dose not seem to bead up the beautiful way it did for you it gust kinda spreads across the glass how did you do it.

Pater Noster
by jmsetzler

Comment by twm122:
Nice shot, but you didn't need the border - gave it a 6

Pater Noster
by jmsetzler

Comment by BrennanOB:
nice composition but just too grainy for the subject matter IMHO.

Pater Noster
by jmsetzler

Comment by Kavey:
The grain works really well. Really adds to the texure in the subject matter itself.

Pater Noster
by jmsetzler

Comment by love:
very effective use of grain, b&w - 9

Pater Noster
by jmsetzler

Comment by AndrewTO:
I like this picture, I think that black and white rendition plus a bit of grain add to the ipact and make it clearly stand out. Hope it will finish well. (10)

Pater Noster
by jmsetzler

Comment by rlinn3:
Love the grain for the moody effect.