It Electrifying!
by Wildpurple

Comment by Pixelstate:
interesting shot. Not sure that this wouldn't have looked better in color?

It Electrifying!
by Wildpurple

Comment by Brenb:
Cool shot.

Super Dog
by Wildpurple

Comment by GeneralE:
I'm not sure I like the red that much, but I do like the grainy, posterized look -- I try and picture this as a poster for a 1950's "B" movie ... : )

Super Dog
by Wildpurple

Comment by fotodude:
of all the dog shots in this challenge (and there are alot) this is by far the coolest as well as the most well done of any of them.

the dog looks just right for the shot and gives that great i'm proud to be a dog look if only we knew what he was thinking... great shot well taken

Super Dog
by Wildpurple

Comment by Artyste:
I like this. The style this photograph is in works really well, composition is wonderful, and the look of the dog's face is brilliant.

Super Dog
by Wildpurple

Comment by floyd:
Yet more selective desaturation with naught but the most threadbare purpose. 6

It Electrifying!
by Wildpurple

Comment by Dr.Confuser:
Nice curves in this beautiful abstract.

June
by Wildpurple

Comment by tristalisk:
Greetings from the Critique Club :)

I think this is an excellent 'abstract' image. I'm not sure how this photo was intended to fit the title, so I don't know how well the image represents that.

I think the pink background in this image may be slightly overpowering.This makes the rose appear black and kills most of the details. I think another improvement on this shot would be different lighting. I say this for the same reason as before. I just can't tell if intended for the rose to be black. The two dark shadows on the bottom right, and top left edge of the frame is somewhat distracting. It looks almost as if this is actualy the lense of the camera causing a ring. However I asume this is just a lighting problem. So this could have been fixed by tighter cropping or slightly different lighting.

my overall perspective of this image, IMO, needs something more. It has too much blank space, and not enough detail. I have had good luck in situations like this one using darker backrounds and use my soft lighting to illuminated the subject a little more.

I can see the direction you were going for with this shot. I feel it was a great idea and would have been a great photo if it had worked the way you had planed.


I hope that the lack of commnents and score you received by posting this image here were not hurtful. You have to take these responses with a grain of salt and keep on plugging :)

Troy Hayward

It Electrifying!
by Wildpurple

Comment by alien2thisworld:
Very interesting shot. I like the sharp focus of the subject.

It Electrifying!
by Wildpurple

Comment by moswyn:
Not sure what it is, but it makes for a neat piece of art! Points off for that spot on the bottom of the image, though.