Making the Cut
by adine

Comment by jodiecoston:
Very well done. Possibly, imho, the most creative idea of the challenge. The message jumps out at you and communicates effectively. Technically well executed, good dynamic composition. Grea t work. 10

Magic Flute
by adine

Comment by dsidwell:
You found the perfect way to show air going through this instrument. Add a touch of drama with composition and lighting and viola! You've got a great picture! 10

Magic Flute
by adine

Comment by agwright:
the best i have seen 10/10

Anticipation
by adine

Comment by pncowley:
Very nice shot... but in my opinion, the bright red border detracts from the overall quality. --7

Anticipation
by adine

Comment by Dallas_TX:
great, great shot!!

Whirl
by adine

Comment by KarenB:
Critique Club:

Initial: great texture.

Composition: This is pretty straight forward. It is documenting a pine cone.

Technical: Focus and clarity is very nice...it does tend to make it stand right out of the frame, and the lighting adds to the 3D effect, so that is done very well.. only suggestion I would make is to use a reflector to fill in the shadows within the pine cone if possible. Use of duotone is done effectively.

Emotive? Not really. Interesting? Limited.

Anticipation
by adine

Comment by KarenB:
I have 2 words for this: "Oh, yum!!"
nice macro.. I like how the chocolate swirls, and how there is only a hint of the fork, yet enough to know what it is. nice job!

Anticipation
by adine

Comment by autool:
Nice work, I would have liked it with a little more light under the berry. 6

Magic Flute
by adine

Comment by frisca:
very neat effecti with the smoke. Great composition. I like the choice of sepia too, the contrast is very nice.

Magic Flute
by adine

Comment by sagestudio:
This is very cool, and would make a great print.