Four Elements
by eac

Comment by bob_bobski:
Nice shot getting in all four elements

sittingonthegrass
by eac

Comment by BlueZamia:
This seems soft and dark to me.

Little Fisherman
by eac

Comment by J-Me:
This may not be the most technically well done shot in this challenge, BUT.....for some reason, it really struck me and I'm giving this a 9! Anything that puts a smile on my face gets a high mark! This one did!

sittingonthegrass
by eac

Comment by patio127:
That's perfect !

sittingonthegrass
by eac

Comment by Arina_Rin:
I don't know about your subject. the dog looks like he's about to do something and seems incomplete

sittingonthegrass
by eac

Comment by crayon:
the lighting isn't bright enough here.

Little Fisherman
by eac

Comment by saracat:
Nice isolation of subject through the use of the desat.

Little Fisherman
by eac

Comment by Haneck:
Neat idea! I would suggest adding a little contrast, and changing the composition. PLacing the subject in the center isn't a really good idea... :)but otherwise, good job!

Little Fisherman
by eac

Comment by bubeltrubel:
the fisherman is out of focus, IMO

Lightning across the lake
by eac

Comment by yanko:
The sky is very dreary. I'd try and play that up more with your editing by making it darker and perhaps converting to b/w. Also, the shapes just aren't interesting in this composition. To try and remedy that going with a square crop may work better (i.e. removing most of the right side). The parts that are most interesting is the lightning but also the foreground boulders are bigger on the left side and the land across the lake tapers off to the left which may add some dynamic to the shot if it was more a focus. Just a thought.