Carefree
by guybrowme

Comment by inspzil:
nice shot. I don't like the haze, but I know it's not always about things over which you have no control. Good Job - Inspzil 6

Carefree
by guybrowme

Comment by Jak:
After this contest, when you can clean up the spots, this will be a cherished photograph. 8 Jak

A bark bark here
by guybrowme

Comment by autool:
Composition: Subject Placement, Cropping, Background7,
Technical: Focus, Exposure, Lighting, Processing7,
Challenge: Does your entry meet it?8,
Appeal: Is it Interesting, Motivating, Etc.? 7,
Total Averaged Rating7. Autool

A bark bark here
by guybrowme

Comment by Swashbuckler:
Framing and cropping seem less than wonderful (note: the bottom and left sides are the hardest to look at, but the other two sides aren't great either) And your contribution to this person's art is???? Photo is nicely focused. 6 Swash

A bark bark here
by guybrowme

Comment by Jak:
The angle of the book takes away from the image, but I like it well enough. 7 Jak

A bark bark here
by guybrowme

Comment by galblue:
e i ei ouch

A bark bark here
by guybrowme

Comment by chilibonze:
terrible. its just a straight on image that isnt even yours. Im all for sampling in an artistic way, but you havent done anything with it to make it more interesting

A bark bark here
by guybrowme

Comment by HBunch:
This looks like a photo of a page in a book. I realize that it is childhood related, but I don't think it took much effort. For being such a simple photo (in my mind) there should be no technical flaws, yet the angle and frame are off. The lighting is great, you did a wonderful job keeping annoying glare and reflection off the page, and there are no distracting shadows. Old McDonald definately reminds me of childhood. Good luck in the challenge.

A bark bark here
by guybrowme

Comment by jmsetzler:
Don't take this personally, but i believe that photographing a page from a book like this is a little less creative that I like. Granted, this is a childhood book, but showing just this page in a full frame is 'borrowing' from someone else's creativity rather than creating your own... - jmsetzler

A bark bark here
by guybrowme

Comment by byetko:
This photo is a little dark for my taste and Im not sure how exactly but I think it should have been cropped differently. 5.