Wagon in the West
by puckin

Comment by adeldegan:
Seems flat, I would have liked to see a different perspective of the wagon.

Wagon in the West
by puckin

Comment by eamurdock:
Nice subject, and well processed; you can see lots of great detail in the wood grain and such. Compositionally a bit dull, and the background is cluttered, which distracts from the subject.

Wagon in the West
by puckin

Comment by dewdodesign:
Hmmmm i could imagine this would have been a very hard image to capture, especially with all the snow and reflection around, so technically you've done really well. There is only one thing that lets this down IMO and that is the background, it is simply too dark and too busy which detracts from the cart itself and means it doesn't stand out as much as it could. If anything it would have been better if there was more snow covering the dark rocks in the background then the brown cart would have been against a white background and it would have stood out a lot more.

Wagon in the West
by puckin

Comment by Benzgirl:
2

Sunrise on the Rock
by puckin

Comment by mariahdc:
Nice but nothing out of the ordinary. 4

Sunrise on the Rock
by puckin

Comment by DrAchoo:
A bit on the soft side. Lowering the midtones might have made the reds and blues a bit more rich. 5

Sunrise on the Rock
by puckin

Comment by tatami:
Good shot. I wish it was a bit sharper.

Sunrise on the Rock
by puckin

Comment by xodiak:
I'm glad you shot this from below (probably didn't have much of a choice huh?). It really makes the outcroping look huge. Nicely done.

Nothin but net?
by puckin

Comment by Simms:
dull and uninspiring. it meets the challenge, but only `by the numbers`. 3

Munchkin
by puckin

Comment by IreneM:
Beautiful.