Odd One Out
by starblazer

Comment by tomzinho:
is the odd one out the bicycle or the black motorcycle? at first i thought it was the bicycle until i realized that the photo had been desaturated except for red. a different angle might have made this more clear and the photo more powerful.

Odd One Out
by starblazer

Comment by magnus:
But it isn't an odd *one* out, there's red all over the scene! Besides, the compression artifacts are real problem

Odd One Out
by starblazer

Comment by cpanaioti:
Red is a very strong colour and distracts the viewer from the main subject. More impact would have been achieved if the odd one out was the red bike instead of the black one. Another thing to try would be to have the odd one out about 2/3 of the way back and use depth of field to blur the foreground and background.

Odd One Out
by starblazer

Comment by mullany1957:
Good concept but it looks too monochrome for my taste. -6-

Odd One Out
by starblazer

Comment by marbo:
Oh this must be the Sony Mavica FD-73 camera. So you must be one of the class of students that have a unique way of leaving identical comments for every photo. I don`t care for that very much but this photo is probaly the best one yet with this rather limited camera.
Good luck. 8

Odd One Out
by starblazer

Comment by goodtempo:
the color does not look right, it distracts from this image rather than enhances it.

Odd One Out
by starblazer

Comment by kiwiness:
Wow, bike salad! Interesting effect desturating all but red.

Late!
by starblazer

Comment by Gracious:
Critique Club Comments by Grayce
Nicely interpreted of the challenge. It meets the challenge very well.
Depth of field is good, with everything being in good sharp focus.
Your exposure is also quite good, with no burned out spots nor lack of detail.
It looks as if this was thought out and carefully executed. I notice that some object to set up pictures. I think it just adds to your credit to not leave things to chance. Even though you planned this out I think it actually looks quite natural. It would probably make a good stock shot too.
Good work!
Regards,

Grayce

Late!
by starblazer

Comment by karmat:
Great idea and wonderful execution. I don't know how much effort it took to set this up, but it flows nicely, and doesn't look too cluttered! I can also relate to this, because this was the stuff of nightmares when I was in college!

Late!
by starblazer

Comment by KarenB:
ooops.. looks like you are late.. hehehe
nice idea.. glad to see some interpretation to the challenge.