Kettles 1914 to 2003
by sulamk

Comment by 'Pong:
Too much on PS, IMO

Double Vision
by sulamk

Comment by tcherring:
CRITIQUE CLUB

Challenge: Met the challenge perfectly, but a little too much focus is on the flower.

Technique: Your lighting is awesome! The colors are very warm and inviting, and the "off centered" approach makes it interesting to look at. The reflection is great and very "clean"

Overall: A GREAT shot! I scored this one a 7 in the competition, and it is very well done. Very original and fun to look at.

Double Vision
by sulamk

Comment by Gracious:
I like the idea of this...the reflection. The background works real well. There seems to be too many elements in the picture though. They don't seem to all go togther...nothing that really binds them. Does that make sense to you? Too much to look at. I can't figure out what the thing is, that the egg is in. It looks sort of high tech. Also the thing sticking out of it, looks like a toothbrush handle.
The flower (?) competes with the subject.
With just the egg in the holder, it would make a good, very good abstract. Remove the stick and flower and I think you have a first class pic.
Technically this looks fine. Your exposure, focus, and post processing are very good. It's framed well too.
Regards,

Grayce

Double Vision
by sulamk

Comment by Becky:
Thelit is nice.

Double Vision
by sulamk

Comment by calaille:
Great colour, reflection and lighting. Would be even better if the shot was a little bit more centred. 7

Double Vision
by sulamk

Comment by Dustin:
Good job. Nice pic.

Double Vision
by sulamk

Comment by mariomel:
Wondeful reflection. Beautiful.

Double Vision
by sulamk

Comment by MattW:
good idea

Double Vision
by sulamk

Comment by jmsetzler:
excellent work with the reflections... i really didn't think anyone would be able to work a flower into this challenge effectively :) - setzler

Double Vision
by sulamk

Comment by kiwiness:
Good mirror shot. You could almost turn it 180 degrees and no one would no the difference. Except that the lighting might be a little too harsh coming from the right on the top. Good choice of border.