Rock in its naturally Sitting
by Crafty Sue

Comment by Chinabun:
this wouldve probably been a great photo but it looks out of focus

Rock in its naturally Sitting
by Crafty Sue

Comment by Evaan:
Nice composition, but, needs to be sharper.

Rock in its naturally Sitting
by Crafty Sue

Comment by RolandB:
Photo appears to be oversharpened and still not sharp. Colors are too harsh for my eyes. The main subject is overexposed.

Rock in its naturally Sitting
by Crafty Sue

Comment by saracat:
Out of focus and over saturated.

Rock in its naturally Sitting
by Crafty Sue

Comment by Zed Pobre:
Lighting and focus seem abnormal. Highlights are blown at the top of the rock, leading to painful glare.

Birthday Rose 2.jpg
by Crafty Sue

Comment by Marjo:
A beautiful rose for the birthday girl! Happy belated Birthday!

Wet Rose after the rain
by Crafty Sue

Comment by lewiss:
Slightly soft focus, but nice colour and background.

Wet Rose after the rain
by Crafty Sue

Comment by Skip:
what lovely colors you've captured. i hope you are getting some good comments and suggestions, and not getting overlooked in this super-sized challenge. if you aren't getting the scores and comments you wanted, please don't take it personally; just consider it a starting point for the rest of the year. good luck with this and the challenges yet to come!

Wet Rose after the rain
by Crafty Sue

Comment by dwterry:
A little more sharpness and detail in the rose would help... But the shallow depth of field for the background is good.

Wet Rose after the rain
by Crafty Sue

Comment by ahaze:
Pretty colors. Hard to tell where the focus is since the DOF is so shallow.