Solid/Liquid
by sfarrell23

Comment by bayonic:
something different for a change .... simple is beautiful

7

Solid/Liquid
by sfarrell23

Comment by thunderbug:
solid and liquid arent opposites

"Rusty Underside"
by sfarrell23

Comment by boomer:
While I like everything about your image, including the frame, I wish there was a bit more "context" in it -- a building, perhaps. The angle is pretty good but leaves so much negative space lower left. Maybe cropped off about an inch down below? 6

"Rusty Underside"
by sfarrell23

Comment by heida:
I love this picture, beautiful colors great stuff man :-)

Moving Out...
by sfarrell23

Comment by ddmckinney1954:
nice vibrant colors

"Rusty Underside"
by sfarrell23

Comment by whagerbaumer:
But an amazingly well lit underside. Nice choice of timeof day.

If only the sky were a little deeper blue.

A 7.

Moving Out...
by sfarrell23

Comment by Tranquil:
This was a good idea but probably should have been cropped so as to include the train in the line of the rule of thirds.

Moving Out...
by sfarrell23

Comment by melismatica:
I gave this a five. I like the overall perspective. I think waiting until the train was looming closer in the frame (or moving in closer if it's not a moving train) would have created a more imposing subject. The overall seen is much too contrasty. I don't think you need quite as much sky. If you can go back and do this again (lowering the contrast on your camera if you can) you have the makings of an excellent shot.

Moving Out...
by sfarrell23

Comment by nicklevy:
Nothing to do with the photo by itself and it doesn't affect the score but your title is moving out while the picture suggest moving in...

I like the composition and the colors but the contrast seem to have bee set too high. The light seems very hard in this photo (5)

"Rusty Underside"
by sfarrell23

Comment by autool:
Composition: Subject Placement, Cropping, Background 7
Technical: Focus, Exposure, Lighting, Processing 9
Appeal: Is it Interesting, Motivating, Etc.? 5
How well does it meet the challenge: 9
Total Averaged Rating 7.50 Dick