Eggs On Ice
by MattW

Comment by UberFish:
Id prefer it if you'd contrasted with the old leaves (old dead spiky vs new life soft), the ice is neither here nor there.

Yellow Sink
by MattW

Comment by Lustre:
Unfortunately I didn't get to vote on your image during the challenge. I think your biggest problem was a lack of light. If the image had been bright and smooth then it would have scored much better. There were a lot of angles and lines to add interest to the photo.

If practical I would suggest going back and retaking the photo. Perhaps bounce light off the roof if you want to avoid reflections, but give it plenty of light. One other option might be to try and salvage the photo somewhat using "denoise" or some of the special ISO filters in photoshop.

Yellow Sink
by MattW

Comment by mcrael:
Composition is interesting, but lighting renders the colors as dull.

Yellow Sink
by MattW

Comment by Crafty Sue:
coloring not good

Yellow Sink
by MattW

Comment by Sonifo:
This shot is to grainy and not very interesting. Did you think about using macro setting? Or maybe try a different angle. Take more then one shot. I said my critique know lets see if you will be mad because I was honest.

Yellow Sink
by MattW

Comment by csb:
out of focus, not really much yellow here

Yellow Sink
by MattW

Comment by Dremelman:
Out of focus, too grainy, poor composition and poor color. Sorry.

Yellow Sink
by MattW

Comment by thatguy:
a little blurry, and the water fountain looks more pale

Yellow Sink
by MattW

Comment by Martus:
Interesting perspective. Unfortunately the focus is a little soft, and the subject is not very well lit.

Yellow Sink
by MattW

Comment by Swashbuckler:
Well, it's a drinking fountain. It is kinda yellow, but a very pale version. Cropping seems a bit off (see upper left corner). Focus is good. Difficult subject/setting as there's not enough light (grainy), but more light would have just made the glare much worse. 5 Swash