The Moon Drops Through the Morning's Palette to the Horizon...
by NikonJeb

Comment by Rgarcia:
I gave it an 8! I think its a wonderful image. However, the sky does look a little bit strange in my monitor, specially the blue part. I use a LCD monitor and I've noticed that images that I processed on CRT monitors and looked great on them looked weird and full of artifacts and blotches on the LCD.
Hope this helps. Regards,

Roberto

The Moon Drops Through the Morning's Palette to the Horizon...
by NikonJeb

Comment by jaysonmc:
Hey Jeb, I liked your redo of this image as I feel it is more natural. Still just to say it does have wonderful texture and placement of items.

The Moon Drops Through the Morning's Palette to the Horizon...
by NikonJeb

Comment by breadfan35:
Ok to be honest, this image does nothing for me. But I'm sure that has more to do with my personal taste than anything else. The rainbow sky effect isn't to my liking and I don't like how the tree is kind of a silhouette, but not really. I'd like it to either be one, or not. But hey, your image scored waaaay better than mine so that should tell you how much of my opinion you should value. ;-)

The Moon Drops Through the Morning's Palette to the Horizon...
by NikonJeb

Comment by jmritz:
A 7 from me. Love the color.

The Moon Drops Through the Morning's Palette to the Horizon...
by NikonJeb

Comment by SoulMan1978:
A little oversaturated for me I'm afraid. Nice composition though.

The Moon Drops Through the Morning's Palette to the Horizon...
by NikonJeb

Comment by pineapple:
It's an iconic image of commercial value. But you need to get that artifact-ing under control in the sky. Even at this diminutive size, I can clearly see it and it detracts from the image. Perhaps try running Noise Ninja on the blue and red channels - experiment and make sure that the procedure does not cause posterizing.

The Moon Drops Through the Morning's Palette to the Horizon...
by NikonJeb

Comment by bassbone:
I really like the layers created by the different hues in the sky. The placement of the tree works pretty well. I gave this a 6 during voting, primarily due to the significant color noise I see in the sky - as if the blues and cyans are not balanced when you modified them in Hue/Sat. A bit of smoothing either with a brush or using a noise reduction approach would have likely helped a great deal and bumped that score well over 6.

Cheers!
Peter

The Moon Drops Through the Morning's Palette to the Horizon...
by NikonJeb

Comment by Alicia:
It's an excellent photo and scored fairly well for a FS. I would have given it a 6, had I voted.

The Moon Drops Through the Morning's Palette to the Horizon...
by NikonJeb

Comment by KarenNfld:
Well I gave this a 9 so what do I know. I think the colours are stunning, just beautiful.

The Moon Drops Through the Morning's Palette to the Horizon...
by NikonJeb

Comment by rider:
hi jeb! i gave you a 6 liked the shot but thought the colors near horizon were a bit overdone