Arrogance
by Haneck

Comment by krgl:
9 !

Blue Haze
by Haneck

Comment by Simpa:
nice...

Blue Haze
by Haneck

Comment by locutus:
The sky gradient is pleasing to the eye. But nothing else really grabs me about this. Sorry.

Blue Haze
by Haneck

Comment by JustinM:
Uninteresting composition.

Blue Haze
by Haneck

Comment by Melethia:
Sweet - nice, simple, quiet, and striking. I like.

Torn Memories
by Haneck

Comment by hdogg4u:
:::Critique Club Here:::

First Impression: Just couldnt figure our what it was at first. Slowly started making sense some kind of chest or travel bag. The wow factor was not there though. (4)

Technical: Composition is just too centered. I understand the section you were trying to show but I think a different angle could haver really changed that. Also would have eliminated the hotspot caused by the flash on the left side by the rivets. (4)

Appeal: Once again there was'nt the wow effect. Very difficult to add the wow the effect in a photograph like this but using maybe a different angle with a closer crop could have added a little more to the overall appeal by involving the texture of the chest, handle, and handle rivets. (4)

Challenge: Meets the challenge or brown since there are difinetly various shades of brown within the photograph. (10)

Title: The title helped understand what the photograph was conveying about the old chest (10)

Overall: (6) Some areas of improvement and thats what learning is all about. (What do they say "everyone is a critic")

Hiral Patel

Torn Memories
by Haneck

Comment by Jason_Cross:
Very nice detail, great lighting and super cool tone. 8

Torn Memories
by Haneck

Comment by TCGuru:
Love the cracks and aging on the trunk, it shows that there are actually "memories" to be had here... I am curious to know where that ticket was to!

Torn Memories
by Haneck

Comment by photom1946:
nice job, a 5

Torn Memories
by Haneck

Comment by Ann:
Great! Would be a 10 if the reflection on the left side weren't so harsh.