oak
by idp

Comment by Ken:
Nice job on the B&W. 7

dock
by idp

Comment by angela_packard:
love the black and white...a little different composition would hlep...but still a good shot! 9

rise
by idp

Comment by Blackbox:
It looks like something that I don't want to know what it is...10

dock
by idp

Comment by pineapple:
I like the industrial look of your evening photo. It has a perfect stillness after a day's work feeling. The shadows and half-lights are very attractive.

rise
by idp

Comment by posthumous:
love your composition and the way this ugly form "rises" with a dramatic glow behind it. visually exciting. Why not make it bigger? 9

dock
by idp

Comment by JunieMoon:
Composition is well done and your lights came out really well. It is very dark, though. Can't really see a dock. Maybe the contrast was adjusted too much?

oak
by idp

Comment by cheegirl:
Very cool tree, looks like a scary tree off a horror movie

dock
by idp

Comment by twm122:
I love the feel of this one. I really like your b/w conversion here.

dock
by idp

Comment by Jaded_Housewife:
lovely. id crop out the dark black building ont he right but otherwise fantastic. 7

dock
by idp

Comment by Konador:
Composition: 6 - The composition focuses attention in the right places, but I feel the buildings need a little more space to "breathe", by perhaps having more sky or more water.
Technical: 6 - Lacks any real highlights, the brightest part being a grey, but overall not bad.
Creativity: 5 - The lights amongst the silhouettes are a nice touch, but lack of any real focal point (perhaps something floating in the water?) leaves the photo looking fairly lifeless.
Appeal: 5 - Interesting shapes and contrasts are presented, but it doesnt really do a lot for me personally.

Overall Calculated Average Score: 5