Smokin
by cassber

Comment by vontom:
Composition: 5, Technical: 4, Appeal: 3, Challenge: 5, Overall Calculated Average Score: 4

Puppy's Nose
by cassber

Comment by teachme53:
I know as a member of the critique club I am suppose to enlighten the photographers with words of wisdom. But you got me here...My take on the picture is the dog is looking for a place to piss. i.e. a sign post. If so, where is the post? As far as the picture is concerned, I do like the close up shot. This is something I encourage my students to do all the time. Only if their camera can handle the image. A macro lens was need here, if you don't have one it is worth the money to purchase one. I'm not familiar with your Minolta but if it is not an SLR Digital a macro should come with the camera. If so use it. JG

Puppy's Nose
by cassber

Comment by KarenB:
Yes, I too would like a comment from you! ;0) I would like to know if I was right -- see my comment during the challenge.

Puppy's Nose
by cassber

Comment by tomzinho:
what were your thoughts on this submission? i like less obvious submissions and so if there is something i missed here i'd like to know . . .

Message edited by author 2003-01-27 01:12:55.

Puppy's Nose
by cassber

Comment by mcrael:
And the connection with road signs is......?????? Composition is good, but focus needs some work.

Puppy's Nose
by cassber

Comment by David Ey:
and a heck of a nose it is too

Puppy's Nose
by cassber

Comment by jgillard:
You want a bad score don't you. Well, you are getting one ;) I would give you zero if I could, but I find this submission funny, as it has nothing to do with signs at all. I can not even think of anything ;D jgillard1

Puppy's Nose
by cassber

Comment by nds:
This one really made me laugh, thank you!! Nevertheless, good luck for the challenge...

Puppy's Nose
by cassber

Comment by johnny_justjohnny:
ten. creativity conquers all.

Puppy's Nose
by cassber

Comment by KarenB:
People are just not going to get that a dog smelling out \"road sign\" is important to the search effort of missing or criminal individuals! Good for you for thinking out of the box. Unfortunately, I predict you will not do so well. :(
Nice aspect/angle. A bit too out of focus, even in the areas that should be .. not talking about DOF. Good try! Great effort!