Juxtaposed
by jad

Comment by mpreslar:
I am hard pressed to call the tree the subject of this image. Great ship though!!!

Juxtaposed
by jad

Comment by bmartuch:
The main subject seems to be the boat and not the tree.

Juxtaposed
by jad

Comment by pineapple:
That's an interesting location. Pity about the camper and all the modern items lying about... Nice tones too.

Juxtaposed
by jad

Comment by Caltrop:
i get what you were trying here but the tree plays such a secondary role in the picture that it doesn't quite do it for me. Cool pic of the ship though.

Juxtaposed
by jad

Comment by Pug-H:
As with many people, I guess, I don't find that the tree is the main subject of this photo. It's too bad about all the vehicles on the wharf...

Juxtaposed
by jad

Comment by Shermy:
Wow! A pirate ship! Or at least thats what I thought it was :P I really like it even if its not :P

Juxtaposed
by jad

Comment by renegade1966:
It seems as though the ship is the main object and the tree just happens to be in the bacgground. I like the photo of the ship but, doesn't seem to meet challenge.

Juxtaposed
by jad

Comment by crewmnd:
I get the juxtaposition, but doesn't meet the challenge for me

Juxtaposed
by jad

Comment by Haakon:
This really isn't a bad photo, but I'm afraid that it doesn't meet the requirements of the challenge. Yes, there's a single tree, but I think you'd be hard pressed to show this picture to random strangers on the street and get a response that the tree is the main subject of the image. As far as the image itself is concerned, the composition is very nice, and the image is sharp, so good points for that. I'm not crazy about the sepia tone, but that could just be personal preference. Maybe try starting out with the original colors and then lower the saturation for the channels you don't want to emphasize as much. That way we don't lose the rich colors of the ocean or the sky, but you still have control over the feel of the image. All in all, I think this photo is fine - but I think you will lose points for the ship taking center stage.

Juxtaposed
by jad

Comment by robinssong:
My eye goes to the ship first, then the tree. Nice photo...of a ship! :)