5.3800 for "Crashing Waves"
by hahn23

Comment by MadMan2k:
If this only gets that score the voters are on crack. If it were obviously meeting a given challenge it'd easily be over seven, but I say 6.8

5.3800 for "Crashing Waves"
by hahn23

Comment by tome:
5.9 is my prediction. I'm giving you a 6, it's a nice bw conversion (maybe needs a tad more black) but I'm struggling with the composition in the foreground. It could be unavoidable as it is.
I bet those clouds move really fast over the mountain, I've seen that recently where I live.

5.3800 for "Crashing Waves"
by hahn23

Comment by Neil:
Definitely going to score better than 5.38. But for some reason, the tones on the land look very flat in this. I also thin the bottom crop is too abrupt, leaving fragments of dark patches bottom left of center. I'd say at least 6.4

5.3800 for "Crashing Waves"
by hahn23

Comment by posthumous:
you are definitely too low in your guess. There is a certain majesty to this photo that will take your score higher. They won't like the black and white, though, causing foreground elements to blend into each other (i.e., the trees get lost). A five from me and from DPC a 5.9

5.3800 for "Crashing Waves"
by hahn23

Comment by Tiny:
This all lots kinda weird from here, but its ok for that score.

5.3800 for "Crashing Waves"
by hahn23

Comment by SEG:
I think this is one of best. Not Sure if DPC will though. I think you do gain an advantage in this challenge by not following the rules because your title points the viewer where you want them to and I do not know if I would have automatically noticed how the clouds appear to be waves in this image without it. You deserve higher than your guess. I also think the B&W takes away from this image,. The mountain, grass, and trees blend into each other and its hard to see where one object stops and the next starts. 6 from me

My guess is 5.884

5.3800 for "Crashing Waves"
by hahn23

Comment by chalice:
This is among a relatively small number of images that I think will score well. 6.3

5.3800 for "Crashing Waves"
by hahn23

Comment by bvy:
Sky is a little overwhelming. Should be a crowdpleaser. 6.1

5.3800 for "Crashing Waves"
by hahn23

Comment by tvsometime:
I believe this should do more like a 6.28. An enviable capture of good mountains and exceptional clouds. Seven from me.

5.3800 for "Crashing Waves"
by hahn23

Comment by wbanning:
I gave it a six. Guessing a 5.8.