Baking Soda, Cider Vinegar, Food Coloring and a Beaker (quite original huh?)
by timfythetoo

Comment by Qart:
Excellent work Tim... Right ON!

Silhouette
by timfythetoo

Comment by ambaker:
Critique Club Review:

Very nice colors. And very creative in getting a tree on a ridge where there wasn't one.

Exposure, color, saturation and hues are done well. Brightness and contrast are also excellent.

It's that darn sky.... It seems too tall. I've been sitting here with a piece of paper up to the screen to try to figure out a better crop. But I keep going up, up, up. There doesn't seem to be a good place to end it.

The cloud pattern at the top is distracting in its difference from the rest. The pattern looks almost like somebody laid something on the non-existant negative or slide.

I also like very much the transition of the colors from the horizion to the upper sky.

I think you did an extrodinary job with what you had to work with.

Baking Soda, Cider Vinegar, Food Coloring and a Beaker (quite original huh?)
by timfythetoo

Comment by thegrandwazoo:
This is cool man! Thanks Tim!

:-D

Baking Soda, Cider Vinegar, Food Coloring and a Beaker (quite original huh?)
by timfythetoo

Comment by Judi:
This is what I was trying to do but my Baking Soda....had died!!! Oh no!! So I went with Soda and Salt.

Baking Soda, Cider Vinegar, Food Coloring and a Beaker (quite original huh?)
by timfythetoo

Comment by smurfguy:
Nice sharp focusing, simple background, stark color scheme. The only thing is that the green seems grainy.

...
by timfythetoo

Comment by dunamis:
Clever

Silhouette
by timfythetoo

Comment by Melethia:
'Tis a good "average DPC" shot - aka much better than the average person would shoot, but only average for DPC and not as good as you're used to. I'm not entirely sure I like the balance - the tree takes too much space to be "minimalistic". I'm thinking a long horizontal shot might be the ticket, though obviously not possible from the way this was framed.

Baking Soda, Cider Vinegar, Food Coloring and a Beaker (quite original huh?)
by timfythetoo

Comment by fellajr:
I would think more focus and detail from bottle and flask would have made a better shot.

Silhouette
by timfythetoo

Comment by Kelli:
Trading post...
Very lovely colors in the sky. The upper clouds in the top right seem more like noise though. I know it's not, but the other clouds seem smooth and flowing. I might have cloned them out. The tree could have used some more definition. It is a nice silhouette though. I guess in a nice way I'm trying to say, it's not a bad shot, but it's not really up to the standards you've been setting for yourself. I gave it a 5 in voting.

Papaya Seeds or Mantis Eggs?
by timfythetoo

Comment by Dave Gordon:
I hope it's the former - it doesn't meet the challenge if it's manitis eggs! Pretty colors and detail.