Eye of the Tunnel
by posthumous

Comment by rooum:
I think this is great. Love the water drops. They really make the shot.

Yellow Magic Orchestra
by posthumous

Comment by Wishingdove:
Huh?

Energy Squared
by posthumous

Comment by Ecce_Signum:
Greetings from Andi via the Critique Club

First Impression: Didn't have you down for shooting this Don however I did think that rather than a shot at the brown this was more about making a statement and guess you suceeded ;)

Composition: I like your composition, a nicely filled frame with something to look at where ever your eyes fall.

Subject: I've looked at this for a little while now and been counting the 'implied' or part squares and tbh for me it actually fits the challenge topic well

Technical: Good exposure and focus apart from the ropes that look a little blown out for me and would have preferred some more detail in them though am guessing its white nylon in which case even properly exposed they would appear blown.

Final thoughts: Brown Ribbon material? maybe if it was posted in the circles challenge. No, it was never going to score highly but a 3.7 was undeserved imho and kudos for thinking out of the square!

Energy Squared
by posthumous

Comment by cutout:
O

Yellow Magic Orchestra
by posthumous

Comment by oscarthepig:
Lots of great stuff to look at here. Cool textures and shapes.

Eye of the Tunnel
by posthumous

Comment by Yo_Spiff:
This will probably get killed in voting, but I like this semi abstract approach. It draws me in a and gives me a sense of intense activity.

Flying
by posthumous

Comment by Chinarosepetal:
Oh, I thought the flower was dreaming of being a tree, I can see his dream, blurrily behind him....

saxjazz
by posthumous

Comment by Budya:
Greetings from the Critique Club!

I must admit that it is really hard for me to critique this photo as I really, really like it.

Larus's comment captures pretty well what did not work for majority of the voters -- it is a b&w abstract.

I love the sense of movement, the contrast and a superb b&w conversion. I like how the brushstrokes lead my eye through the photo, letting me appreciate the textures of the old oil painting along the way. This is phenomenally moody and poetic photo that unfortunately appealed to a very small number of voters.

Energy Squared
by posthumous

Comment by skewsme:
square: to bring approximately to a right angle sad but had to be done

Dorothy the Wizard
by posthumous

Comment by colorcarnival:
I didn't even notice the ankles being cropped. I just thought it was funny that the balloon was eating the person. Interesting shot.