lumberjack
by posthumous

Comment by salmiakki:
Greetings from the Critique Club Don.

It's been a while since I've done a critique club comment, so bear with me, I'm a bit rusty. I also always find it challenging to do an in depth critique of your images for some reason I can't quite put my finger on.

I suppose it was no surprise to you to get a lowish vote, as it's totally an out of the box image when thinking of the challenge topic. I see where you are coming from now when lingering over it, but probably, had I voted in the challenge, would have also scratched my head a bit wondering how it fitted.

However, as a standalone image I rather like it. I like the composition and don't find anything to complain about concerning the black and white conversion. It made me think, which is a good thing. Therefore, in conclusion despite the low score, I still think it's a good 'un.

cEnter
by posthumous

Comment by mariuca:
Has all the endearing charm of a simple life.

cEnter
by posthumous

Comment by jnenvir:
Clever idea, center of roll should be brighter.

samsara
by posthumous

Comment by tanguera:
Congrats on the fish!

samsara
by posthumous

Comment by tnun:
it has its own light/life.

samsara
by posthumous

Comment by bspurgeon:
Simply wonderful

.

overshadowed
by posthumous

Comment by mcaldo:
Love her expression and connection with the photographer. I am not sure if the soft focus adds or detracts a bit, but then I am unsure which of the two is the main subject, so it probably creates a connection between the two.

samsara
by posthumous

Comment by mariuca:
Wonderful

overshadowed
by posthumous

Comment by IAmEliKatz:
Cant see the kid.

summoning the bat man
by posthumous

Comment by herfotoman:
First thought it was hand shadow night.