Unforgiven
by Phil

Comment by Rikki:
I like the simplicity of the image but the frame unfortunately ruins it for me. I think the drop shadow is a bit distracting.6

Unforgiven
by Phil

Comment by Skip:
first, the border is just too much. it makes the image more about the border than what's inside it. second, i think i can see what you're after, just wish there was a little more detail. as is, it seems a bit out of balance, with that bright area to the right.

Unforgiven
by Phil

Comment by Konador:
I'm not at all keen on the border here, it really spoils the shot in my opinion. The shot could have looked much more impressive with either a black border or no border. I really think it has enough of a natural border around the subject to not require a new one.

Unforgiven
by Phil

Comment by ubique:
This has some great jagged edges (metaphorically as well as literally), that makes it so convincing for the concept expressed in the title. Would it be as powerful without the title? I'm not sure, but I think so. Therefore: 8.

Unforgiven
by Phil

Comment by shudderbug:
a very moody artistic image - nicely done

Unforgiven
by Phil

Comment by arlanbart:
Good image. Nice lighting. I think a little too much noise. Border is slightly overwhelming as well for a simple composition.

Unforgiven
by Phil

Comment by yanko:
Don't like the drop shadow.

.
by Phil

Comment by Phil:
.

Message edited by author 2008-02-03 14:13:07.

.
by Phil

Comment by docpjv:
I can actually feel the tension, apprehention and uncertainty. You did a great job. Have you tried placing the model to the right with more space in front of her?..

.
by Phil

Comment by bucket:
I like this one best..someone the tension from the light behing her works..sooo much tension is really palpable..
I have 2 young kids and can feel my heart beating when think of those days..man tense and wonderful..
you know this shot probably would have been killed in the challenge..it is too creative...
I really like it a lot...