Industrial Sunset
by shirokko

Comment by macrothing:
6 - Nice. Criticism; sun is a little distracting (dominant) on the left. The silhouette effect is good. Perhaps a slightly tighter crop at the bottom, not sure, as does 'work' like it is. Those 12 extra pixels in width would have helped this. Color is nice. Not sure on the frame, perhaps just a fraction too thick, especially at this size, in my opinion.

Industrial Sunset
by shirokko

Comment by verg:
A bit oversharpened, but otherwise a nice picture.

Industrial Sunset
by shirokko

Comment by KarenNfld:
Nice colours, seems a little soft.

Industrial Sunset
by shirokko

Comment by talmy:
I'd crop out the left 1/4 of the frame. The glare there is bad. Otherwise it is very sharp, pleasant, and meets the topic.

Industrial Sunset
by shirokko

Comment by mferg265:
nice.

Nostalgia
by shirokko

Comment by GrayGhost:
Interesting wheel-barrow-like device and composition. Central reeds are a bit too central.

Nostalgia
by shirokko

Comment by phatphoto:
This is a beautiful photo for a not-so-beautiful challenge subject. The only thing that I notice is that the bar and wheel at the center could be sharper, but I'm not wearing my glasses so it may just be my eyes! Overall, nicely done and I like the choice of border. Good luck.

Nostalgia
by shirokko

Comment by fplouffe:
Nice picture and composition. Unfortunately, it looks more antique than garbage. Still a well deserved 6.

Nostalgia
by shirokko

Comment by Mr_Pants:
To me, the barrow (cart?) could be in the frame a little more.

Nostalgia
by shirokko

Comment by cheegirl:
I'd use that its cool , thats good garbage!