The Angler
by manic35

Comment by aprokopiw:
Looks over photoshopped.

The Angler
by manic35

Comment by TheStick:
WoW! What a shot! It might be my screen (or my eyes) but it looks more blue then b/w/gray to me, IMO this would ribbon in the color challenge. 10

Good luck in the challenge!

The Angler
by manic35

Comment by littleda:
Very Beautiful! the border is a nice touch.

The Angler
by manic35

Comment by elhessar:
Very nice photo but I think it doesn't fits well in B&W in Color. The attention goes to the red horizon.

The Angler
by manic35

Comment by atupdate:
If you had adjusted the blue down just a bit in post processing this would have looked more like a B&W (Not sure if that is legal for this challenge). I consider this a minor issue but I'm afraid it could hurt your score with the DNMC crowd. A minor issue with me and places in my top 10.

The Angler
by manic35

Comment by Gryphx:
I think the bright line of sunlight distracts from the B&W challenge... great picture otherwise!

The Angler
by manic35

Comment by photomankc:
If this would not have any red in it I would have gave it a 6 or 7. Sorry for the 4. You did put some thinking into your shooting. I thank you for that.

The Golden Light of Dusk
by manic35

Comment by notonline:
Certainly has WOW factor but image size suffers a lot because of the site restrictions. Not only would I expect to see this image on a wall but the clarity even for the size is incredible. Very vibrant colors. I really like the lights on the house in the background and find it gives a added touch to this photo. Well done and good luck in this challenge. <10>

The Angler
by manic35

Comment by GIS_boy:
Stunning concept baby, well done. :)

The Angler
by manic35

Comment by davidsocha:
I like the feel of stillness and motion; of waiting at the end of the day; of water above and water below.