Spiral
by susanh

Comment by Bosborne:
Beautiful light and detail. 8

Spiral
by susanh

Comment by pineapple:
Simple and effective. The muted colours are nice. 9.

Spiral
by susanh

Comment by sadiebird:
lovely image. very smooth and serene. bet it also looks cool in b&w

Spiral
by susanh

Comment by RulerZigzag:
beautiful divine proportion. Looks like a galaxy or a hurricane forming. 6

Spiral
by susanh

Comment by Evaan:
Gorgeously lit. Nice clarity and very nice positioning. Very appealing. 10

Spiral
by susanh

Comment by yanko:
Really nice lighting here. Not sure if you noticed but you have some sensor dust in the top right corner and since this is advance editing you should have clone that out. Just a minor nitpick as it didn't effect my score.

Regeneration
by susanh

Comment by whitewolf:
Nice detail, color & composition -

Regeneration
by susanh

Comment by sherpet:
For some reason this really appeals to me, and I think it is the composition, and also how you have cropped it.....Well done.....

Shells & Pebbles
by susanh

Comment by jah_luv:
Great job! Very crisp and clear, great color! I feel as though the swirl has movement, and is almost an optical illusion. I love the smoothness of the stones and the wet feeling of the sand and stones. I am giving this a 9, because it meets the challenge head on in my opinion of what it's all about, but it's not my favorite out of all the entries, so it's not a 10. It's right up there though!

Shells & Pebbles
by susanh

Comment by krnlzbth:
i like the sharpness and depth of fiel, but the speculars are a little distracting