First Submission
by jlr

Comment by CPattee:
the title doesn't work for me, doesn't fit the picture

First Submission
by jlr

Comment by whobee:
would've been GREAT for the garbage challenge.

First Submission
by jlr

Comment by Kavey:
This is a really lovely shot and very strong on texture. The reflection is a little weak.
I think the title is, frankly, manipulative.
Kavey

First Submission
by jlr

Comment by Martin:
great detail and very nice composition/cropping. Only just meets the challange though. 8-Martin

First Submission
by jlr

Comment by amonteforte:
IMHO this is pretty much in focus and the composition of the elements is quite adequate, nevertheless, the reflection, main theme, is vague and unattractive, and the image of an old light bulb with such a grayish, non-contrasting and unappealing background results in a dull photo, that would have probably fared better at the "Garbage" challenge next week.

First Submission
by jlr

Comment by MJOLLNIR:
bad, is THAT IT?

First Submission
by jlr

Comment by willem:
Picture is fine technically, but not strong on the reflection subject.

First Submission
by jlr

Comment by sjgleah:
No strong opinion on this image. Guess I think its novel. 5 sjgleah

First Submission
by jlr

Comment by Gordon:
Welcome! Not a lot of reflection here, but well exposed and it fills the frame. I like the shallow depth of field and blurry background too. Shows promise.

First Submission
by jlr

Comment by clicker:
Congratulations on your first submit!
Welcome aboard! :) Clicker