Marry me ?
by kateto178

Comment by OneSweetSin:
Greetings from the Critique Club

Nice image and definately a delicate question to be asking.

I like your composition but wish the ring was in better focus it seems like the ring would be the most important part in asking the question the rose would just be a finishing touch so in my opinion the ring should be the focus point and be the sharpest thing in the image.

Your lighting is questionable as the white spot on the rose petal is a distraction.

Overall I like this and it has a lot of potential going for it.

Anna

Marry me ?
by kateto178

Comment by Eclectic:
Excellent pic - 8

Marry me ?
by kateto178

Comment by Unicorn_Fighter03:
Romantic..But focus is not good that much..Any way...6 :)

Marry me ?
by kateto178

Comment by secondglantz:
I like the idea and the setup. I wish the ring was a little sharper.

Marry me ?
by kateto178

Comment by Rainybeet:
The ring should be the sharpest part of the photograph. . . right now it looks as though it is a background prop for the flower.

Marry me ?
by kateto178

Comment by chozenfrozen:
Very nice, its too bad the ring is not as sharp as the flower, but good

Marry me ?
by kateto178

Comment by neehai:
Fits the challenge, but the ring is out of focus

Marry me ?
by kateto178

Comment by amandak:
Beautifully done!

Marry me ?
by kateto178

Comment by persimon:
I like the idea, but it lacks the depth that a little color or more contrast would provide. 7

Marry me ?
by kateto178

Comment by Jammur:
Wow, toughy. You did such a wonderful job of keeping the detail in the cloth rose, its a shame the ring is so soft.