Rustscape
by Totem

Comment by sabphoto:
Fits challenge=4
Color/lighting=1
DOF/focus=1
Wow factor/uniqueness=0
Attractiveness=0

seems to lack punch or ability to hold your interest. I have trouble deciding if the orange rust on the right is the subject or maybe the line of black dots on the left.

It's a long way
by Totem

Comment by loseme:
*Critique Club*

This is defiantly a very defined perspective. I think you hit the nail on the head in this subject. The subject itself is interesting but probably not grabbing as much as some when voters are thumbing through the thumbnail. I like the rust spots on the post, it really gives it some character. I wish it was in focus from the base, especially on the left bottom. The top backdrop is very nice, it is what draws me into the image the most, the blue sky is great. It is kind of hard to pin point the subject, I understand it is a post. But it makes you wonder what is at the top of the post. Maybe if it was something a person could stand on that would really grab the viewer. Just my ideas. Very good job on the subject!

Rustscape
by Totem

Comment by Riponlady:
meets challenge but not enough texture, detail to make it interesting

Rustscape
by Totem

Comment by Tammer:
While this photo does fall into the rule of thirds, the subject matter doesn't hold my interest as other entries in this challenge.

Rustscape
by Totem

Comment by bowronfam3:
This in no way meets the Rule of Thirds.

Rustscape
by Totem

Comment by Elaine:
The rivets or screws are not enough of an interest point to me.

Rustscape
by Totem

Comment by cornettcag:
? Rule of thirds?

Rustscape
by Totem

Comment by Drummerjd356:
i dont know what this is...

Rustscape
by Totem

Comment by KarenNfld:
This does not fit the theme

It's a long way
by Totem

Comment by KiwiShotz:
Great subject, tough to light and get that DOF that it needs so badly to score really well